Buyer Red Flags
A Price That Doesn't Make Sense
Be cautious when a desirable or valuable horse is advertised dramatically below what comparable horses would normally sell for.
Scammers sometimes create urgency around an unbelievable deal using explanations such as:
- Owner suddenly relocated
- Divorce
- Military deployment
- Family emergency
- Horse must leave immediately
- Free horse with transportation fee
- Expensive horse offered for a small "rehoming fee"
There may be legitimate reasons for an unusually low price, but an extraordinary bargain deserves more verification, not less.
The Seller Wants a Deposit Immediately
Be cautious if you're pressured to send a deposit before you have had a reasonable opportunity to verify the horse and seller.
Common pressure tactics include:
- "Someone else is sending a deposit tonight."
- "I can't hold him without payment."
- "You have to decide in the next hour."
- "Several people are on their way."
- "The transporter is already scheduled."
A legitimate seller may reasonably require a deposit to hold a horse, but buyers should understand exactly who is receiving the money and what the written deposit terms are before sending it.
Verify the Horse
Stolen and Cloned Horse Listings
Scammers can copy legitimate:
- Horse photographs
- Videos
- Descriptions
- Pedigrees
- Show records
- Farm logos
- Seller biographies
- Social-media content
and create an entirely fake horse listing.
A professional-looking listing does not prove that the seller owns or controls the horse.
Ask for Current Proof
Ask for a new photograph or short video that would be difficult to have prepared in advance.
"Please send me a current video of the horse walking toward the camera and then turning to the left."
Also consider a live video call for higher-value purchases.
AI-Generated and Digitally Altered Content
Modern artificial intelligence makes it increasingly easy to create or alter photographs, voices, documents, websites, and videos.
Do not assume that a professional-looking photograph or video proves that a horse exists or looks exactly as represented.
Image editing alone does not establish fraud. Legitimate sellers may edit photographs for normal photographic purposes.
Buyers should instead consider the entire transaction and independently verify the horse.
For significant purchases, consider:
- Live video
- In-person inspection
- Independent veterinarian
- Registration records
- Competition records
- Breed-association records
- References
Pre-Purchase Examinations
Consider an independent pre-purchase examination appropriate for the intended use and value of the horse.
Ideally, the buyer should select the veterinarian.
Consider discussing:
- Intended use
- Examination scope
- Imaging
- Additional diagnostics
- Known medical information
- Limitations of the examination
A pre-purchase examination is not a guarantee of future health, soundness, or performance.
Verify Registration, Pedigree and Competition Records
When relevant, independently verify:
- Registered name
- Registration number
- Age
- Pedigree
- Ownership
- Competition history
- Earnings
- Breed
- Show results
Do not rely exclusively on screenshots or documents sent by the seller when records can be independently checked.
Verify the Seller
Before sending significant money, research the person or business.
Consider verifying:
- Full name
- Business or barn name
- Phone number
- Email address
- Website
- Social-media history
- References
- Competition history
- Breed-association records
- Professional affiliations where applicable
A new social-media account deserves additional scrutiny.
An established account is not absolute proof of identity because legitimate email and social-media accounts can be compromised.
Verify References Independently
A fraudulent seller can provide the telephone number of an accomplice pretending to be a:
- Veterinarian
- Trainer
- Farrier
- Previous buyer
- Agent
- Transporter
Whenever possible, independently locate the professional or business and contact them through information you found yourself.
If someone says:
"Call Dr. Smith. She's my veterinarian."
consider independently finding the veterinary practice and calling its publicly listed number rather than automatically using the number supplied by the seller.
Payments & Deposits
Payment Red Flags
Use extra caution when someone insists that payment can only be made using:
- Cryptocurrency
- Gift cards
- Wire-transfer services
- Cash
- Payment apps
- Unfamiliar payment websites
Bank wires are commonly used in legitimate high-value transactions. The danger is sending an irreversible payment before independently verifying the recipient and transaction.
Changed Payment Instructions
"Don't send the payment to the account I gave you yesterday. Send it here instead."
Email accounts can be compromised, and criminals may insert themselves into legitimate transactions.
Before sending significant funds, independently verify:
- Recipient
- Bank
- Account instructions
- Reason for any change
Do not rely solely on the email or text that announced the change.
Beware of Fake Transporters
Transportation itself can become part of a scam.
Fraudulent charges may be described as:
- Shipping
- Insurance
- Special transport equipment
- Veterinary clearance
- Refundable transportation deposits
- Quarantine
- Permits
- Emergency fees
Verify the transportation company independently before sending money.
Be particularly cautious when the seller, transporter, insurer, and payment company all came from information supplied by the same person.
Fake Escrow and Buyer Protection Services
Scammers can create professional-looking websites claiming to provide:
- Escrow
- Buyer protection
- Purchase insurance
- Transportation protection
- Deposit guarantees
- Payment guarantees
Important
Black Horse Market does not guarantee a private transaction unless a specific Black Horse Market service expressly states that guarantee on BlackHorse.Market.
Navigate independently to payment or financial services instead of blindly following links sent through email, text, or marketplace messages.
Seller Safety
Fake Checks and Overpayments
A supposed buyer agrees to buy the horse and sends a check for more than the agreed price.
Then they ask the seller to send the extra money to a:
- Transporter
- Agent
- Insurance company
- Third party
A check appearing in a bank account does not necessarily mean it is legitimate.
Never send the "extra" money from an overpayment to someone else.
Buyers Who Don't Care About the Horse
Sellers should use caution when someone immediately agrees to purchase without asking normal questions.
Red flags include:
- No questions about temperament
- No questions about health
- No questions about training
- No questions about location
- No interest in photos or video
- Immediately agrees to asking price
- Offers more than asking price
- Talks mostly about payment and shipping
Keep Early Conversations on Black Horse Market
Legitimate transactions will often eventually involve telephone calls, texts, visits, veterinarians, and other direct communication.
Be cautious when someone immediately insists on moving the conversation away from Black Horse Market before discussing the horse.
Keeping early communications within Black Horse Market may make suspicious activity easier for us to investigate.
Sellers: Be Accurate
Safety is not limited to protecting against fake buyers.
Sellers should accurately represent horses. Do not intentionally misrepresent:
- Age
- Height
- Breed
- Registration
- Competition record
- Training level
- Temperament
- Health history
- Soundness
- Behavioral history
- Ownership
- Location
- Photos
- Videos
What "Verified" Means
We intend to have Verified seller profiles.
A Black Horse Market verification badge means only what Black Horse Market specifically says was verified. It does not automatically mean:
- Black Horse Market guarantees the seller
- Black Horse Market guarantees the horse
- Horse has passed a veterinary inspection
- Horse is sound
- Horse has a particular temperament
- Seller owns every horse listed
- Transaction is guaranteed
Buyers are still responsible for their own due diligence.
Account & Phishing Safety
Protect Your Account
Black Horse Market will never ask users to send their password through:
- Text
- Marketplace message
- Social media
- Telephone
Users should never give another user their:
- Password
- Login credentials
- Verification codes
- Authentication codes
- Password-reset links
- Complete banking information
Watch for Fake Black Horse Market Messages
Common scam messages to watch for:
"Your listing has been suspended."
"Your payment failed."
"Your account must be verified immediately."
"A buyer has paid — click here to collect your money."
"Upgrade your account before your payment can be released."
Instead of clicking a link in a suspicious message, navigate directly to BlackHorse.Market and check your account.
Do Not Trust Caller ID Alone
Telephone numbers can be spoofed.
A familiar area code or business name appearing on caller ID is not proof of identity.
If someone calls claiming to represent a company and asks for sensitive information or payment, independently locate the company's official contact information.
Get the Horse Purchase Agreement in Writing
Buyers and sellers should clearly document their agreement.
Depending on the transaction, the agreement may address:
- Horse's registered name
- Barn name
- Buyer
- Seller
- Purchase price
- Deposit
- Whether the deposit is refundable
- Payment terms
- Pre-purchase examination
- Known health information
- Representations about the horse
- Trial terms
- Transportation
- Transfer of possession
- Registration papers
- Risk of loss
- Other agreed conditions
For significant transactions, consider having an attorney familiar with equine transactions review the agreement.
Something Doesn't Look Right?
If you encounter a suspicious listing, message, buyer, seller, payment request, or transaction on Black Horse Market, stop and report it.
Before reporting, consider saving:
- Screenshots
- Messages
- Emails
- Phone numbers
- Usernames
- Payment instructions
- Receipts
- Listing information
If You Think You've Been Scammed
Act quickly.
Contact the:
- Bank
- Card issuer
- Payment app
- Wire-transfer provider
- Financial institution involved
Tell them you believe the transaction may be fraudulent and ask whether it can be:
- Stopped
- Recalled
- Disputed
- Reversed
For United States users, additional reporting resources are available:
